Compared to the other SX albums, I think the guitars on V are just a little hollow. They lack the bite that Romeo's tone generally has.
I actually think that sound worked perfectly for V. The way that album is composed the guitars are not meant to be screaming, and in your face, as they are on PL (and as they tried to be on The Odyssey). V is more about balance with rich vocal textures and keyboard layers of both chords and harmonic lines. I think on that album they accomplished something that is rarely accomplished in metal production - instrument balance in the best interest of the composition. The guitar is used in such a cool dynamic way on that album, it can be very powerful and upfront like the intro of Evolution, or it can play an ancillary role in support of other textures like the simple descending line under 'Five senses come alive...' in Communion. If that line were biting and in your face it would be compositionally dull and over power the real textures of that section - the keys and the vocal layering. You're right that the tone is a little hollow and often lacks bite - if that were the tone on an album like PL it would not work at all. On V, I think it works in the larger context of that albums presentation.
Compression is not always a problem at the mastering level of things. Compression is usually used to some degree on almost every individual instrument track, there is usually one layered on top of that on the drum kit as a whole, and then one layered on top of THAT on the entire mix. Mastering is usually more about using limiters than compressors really. So to be fair, a mix may be hopelessly over compressed well before it goes to mastering, and you can't undo the compression at that stage of things.
I own every Symphony X album except the S/T and i find V to be the weakest besides TDG
I actually think that sound worked perfectly for V. The way that album is composed the guitars are not meant to be screaming, and in your face, as they are on PL (and as they tried to be on The Odyssey). V is more about balance with rich vocal textures and keyboard layers of both chords and harmonic lines. I think on that album they accomplished something that is rarely accomplished in metal production - instrument balance in the best interest of the composition. The guitar is used in such a cool dynamic way on that album, it can be very powerful and upfront like the intro of Evolution, or it can play an ancillary role in support of other textures like the simple descending line under 'Five senses come alive...' in Communion. If that line were biting and in your face it would be compositionally dull and over power the real textures of that section - the keys and the vocal layering. You're right that the tone is a little hollow and often lacks bite - if that were the tone on an album like PL it would not work at all. On V, I think it works in the larger context of that albums presentation.
Compression is not always a problem at the mastering level of things. Compression is usually used to some degree on almost every individual instrument track, there is usually one layered on top of that on the drum kit as a whole, and then one layered on top of THAT on the entire mix. Mastering is usually more about using limiters than compressors really. So to be fair, a mix may be hopelessly over compressed well before it goes to mastering, and you can't undo the compression at that stage of things.
Exactly - I remember I got V and The Odyssey at the same time, and almost never listened to V. Now it's my favorite. Almost all my favorite albums turn out to be the ones I didn't like at first.V definitely gets better the more you delve into it.
Exactly - I remember I got V and The Odyssey at the same time, and almost never listened to V. Now it's my favorite. Almost all my favorite albums turn out to be the ones I didn't like at first.
I just went through and listened to a few songs off of each album, and I think his tone on Paradise Lost (both lead and rhythm) is the best he's ever sounded to my ears. From a mix/tone/overall production standpoint, I still think it's the best thing they've ever put out.