We might not be listening to ANY of these players if it weren't for Uli Roth. He's the most complete guitarist I've ever heard, from authentic Flamenco, to beautiful, Hendrix-style blues, to neo-classical shred. This guy can can do it all, and he writes great music. Check out Scorpions "The Sails of Charon". One of my favorite solos ever.
My second pick would be Vinnie Moore, who I believe is superior to Malmsteen or Becker in the songwriting department. Those guys are obviously very gifted technically, but their music is lacking compositional strength. It's the same difference you hear between Paganini, who Malmsteen cites as his biggest influence, and Bach, who both Uli and Vinnie have cited as probably their biggest influence.