I won't shoot the messenger, here, 'cause it's not your fault this person has a substandard review, here.
What's interesting is that Captain Paragraph (Chris Dick) speaks of murky production, a lack of dynamics and refers to the songs as average. This coming from a solid paragraph review, speaking in generalities with limited references to REAL things he likes or doesn't.
Personally, it sounds like someone got ahold of one of the Euro-released promos with admitted production issues. It also sounds like someone was ticked because the band moved in a direction they wanted to instead of the direction HE wanted them to go, which is to say, more thrash, less ballady-mid-tempo-DHIADW-stuff. I am a sad clown for him.
I did like the quasi-diverse references to other bands he obviously felt did a better job in certain aspects, though. It shows that he's, you know, not limited in scope to what he listens to...
IMHO, all the stuff that was groused about, with the exception of the production, were things I thought were strengths. I'll also have to ask WD about being rendered "mute," since he came through on my recording loud and clear.
Bah. Hell with reviews. Remember, the media is currently in love with St. Anger....