OCTOBER TIDE POLL:RAIN WITHOUT END vs GREY DAWN

[doom_death]

So,like the title says...which album do you like better? With explanations....know that this isn't best place for that..or maybe it is,because other ones do not exist

 

[katafrenchy]

you should add katatonia album

 

[doom_death]

I wasn't sure what to vote for,because I adore both albums,but in the end Grey Dawn gets my vote...it is great...sweetnes dies,grey dawn,floating...amazing songs...

 

[exy]

Rain without end.

 

[Scourge of Malice]

Grey Dawn. Just sounds more solid and focused to me. Both albums are great though.

 

[cliffburton615]

Rain Without End, its just more miserable.

 

[Hobo]

Grey dawn.
Simply because it´s better.

 

[Francis Xavier]

Havnt hear any material with rain without end
Have had Grey Dawn, was a darn expensive album to order in, but worth it all
All I can say is GRey Dawn has practically the sweetest guitar intro

 

[Jinn]

Rain Without End hands down.

 

[the mourner13]

Rain Without End easily...Losing Tomorrow is one of the best songs I have ever heard,don't kill me but it's even better than Day IMO.

 

[doom_death]

Rain Without End easily...Losing Tomorrow is one of the best songs I have ever heard,don't kill me but it's even better than Day IMO.

Yes,that song is crushing

 

[stefan86]

Rain Without End. It's more consistent, and I like Jonas vocs better.

 

[MadTinus]

Pfff, I need to listen to both albums again, can't choose just now!

 

[doom_death]

Take your time MadTinus

 

[MadTinus]

I just did and my vote went to Grey Dawn.

 

[doom_death]

I am little suprised in just 4 votes for the Grey Dawn...it is far more superb in my opinion...

 

[Tumn]

Easy choice, Rain without end due to the fact that Jonas' growl is much better.

 

[doom_death]

I really like Jonas growling, but for Octobar Tide Hensen did a better job I think...well,both are great,but on Grey Dawn I like vocals better...

 

[MadTinus]

I played both in a row and when I put Grey Dawn in after Rain Without End, it just sounded better, more powerful. I also noticed the riffs and melodies touched me more.

And Hansen does an excellent job on the vocals, very intense.

 

[stefan86]

When it comes down to the growls on the CDs it's essentially a choice between feeling (Jonas) or technical ability (Hansen)