I actually think Ripper would work in Iced Earth. No he wouldn't be like Matt, but he would bring a different style to the band. I think Matt may be a different type of singer than Ripper, but you can't really say better or worse, its all opinion anyway. Matt was (is) an amazing singer, it will be hard to follow him, but can it be harder than following Rob Halford? I saw Priest twice with Rob (Ram It Down, and Painkiller) and once with Ripper (Demolition, the tour Iced Earth was supposed to open before 9/11 happened) After Iced Earth couldn't open, I thought about just selling the tickets, I mean how could anyone follow Rob live? But I figured I'd go watch Anthrax and was all set to be disappointed by Priest..but guess what.. Not only wasn't I disappointed, I was extremely impressed. Ripper hit every note that Rob hits, and he could sing the low notes too. I left the concert glad I hung in there, and amazed by Ripper's ability.
So anyway, I think if this does happen, it would work out pretty well for Iced Earth, more name recognition from a singer who was in Judas Priest, and a singer who can definitely handle himself, and is used to the whole "new guy" thing. No he won't be the same as Matt, he may not be better, he may not be worse, he will just be different. Hopefully that goes for whoever the new singer may be.. I have faith that Jon will make the right choice for Iced Earth.