Recommend me a soldering iron

John_C

formerly Skeksis268
Dec 30, 2008
3,457
1
36
Coventry, UK
www.myspace.com
I've been (attempting) to use a massive beast which for some reason heats exclusively in the places which are useless for soldering.

I'm not looking to spend a lot of money, i don't need anything fancy, i just need something that works and will allow me to attach plugs to cables!
 
I have a Weller SP23L for my Electronics School, its 25 watt and its a great device, its enough power to get hot enough to do just about anything, though I do believe that with a lower wattage its recommended to use lead solder, which you have to be careful with.
 
I bought a real cheap one for doing small jobs like cables, circuits etc and it does the job perfectly. It was only bout 8 euro so you dont need to spend loads. having used Weller, I would say they are a very good make and very reliable. I would say try get one with removable tips and try a couple of tips as when they get black and blunt they arent much use. Most soldering irons have tht feature nowadays now anyway. I always try to find one with the smallest tips so that they are fine enough for a veriety of jobs. nothing worse than a thick tip trying to solder small circuits.
 
that's fine, i can see loads i can buy for practically nothing, if they break i'll buy a better quality one.

Lead/Tin solder? it's what i've always used but what about you guys?
 
I've got one an Aoyue 2900 Lead Free Soldering Station. That thing is freaking awesome, I've built 7 SCA Preamps with it and soldered many cables!
 
what about lead free solder? any good at all?

Not the best IME. The leaded stuff has a much lower melting point, so it's easier to avoid melting the cable insulation etc. In this respect it's also best to use a bigger tip on the iron - you want to get the joint hot quick before the heat starts spreading down the cable.

Like DevilJaw said, use 63/37 percent not 60/40 - the tin and lead will melt and solidify at the same temp, so it places less internal strain on the joint as it cools from the expansion ratios.

The stuff with a little silver content is said to make a bit stronger joint, but I don't use 'cos I'm paranoid over the "red plague" issue (silver can promote oxidation of the copper conductor beneath in conditions of high humidity).

For the flux...don't use stuff from the hardware store, the plumber's flux they sell is too aggressive for electronics. I've used a no-clean flux pen which works very well for me. Roisin is also a good flux, although produces particularly irritant vapour.

Audiophile nutters also claim different solder recipes sound different, but whatever...

Also, never solder the wire and then trim off the excess - always trim first and ensure that the exposed copper is completely covered by solder, otherwise it will oxidise over time.
 
I've been using a Weller WP25 for a few years now and it's just as effective as expensive stations that I've used. I do a lot of PCB and perf board work with it. Using a good solder with lead helps (Kester 60/40 or 63/37).
 
what about lead free solder? any good at all?

In general...not good. Brittle, doesn't flow like lead solder, and it's hard to tell if you have a good solder joint. Lots of issues w related to lead free solder...I shake my fist at the EU for making electronics that much less reliable.