Remember when we used to have those "Rank ______'s Discography" threads?

[Dick Sirloin]

GODDAMN I LOVE THIS BAND

Edge Of Thorns 9/10
Gutter Ballet 9/10
The Dungeons Are Calling 8.5/10
Hall Of The Mountain King 8.5/10
The Wake Of Magellan 8/10
Handful Of Rain 8/10
Dead Winter Dead 8/10
Sirens 8/10
Streets 7.5/10
Poets And Madmen 7.5/10
Fight For The Rock 7/10
Power Of The Night 7/10

 

[NAD]

I have a friend who could rank the Zappa albums. Likely including all the live/weirdo shit too.

Tell me which Savatage album to begin with, and I shall purchase it.

 

[Dick Sirloin]

<-----

 

[NAD]

So let it be written, so let it be done.

 

[einride]

blood fire death
twilight of the gods
hammerheart
under the sign of the black mark
bathory
blood on ice
the return......
nordland II
requiem
nordland I
destroyer of worlds
octagon

 

[Ellestin]

Of Stone, Wind, and Pillor
The Mantle
The White EP
Ashes Against the Grain
Marrow of the Spirit
Pale Folklore
Faustian Echoes
The Grey EP

 

[einride]

i literally can not believe you would hate pale folklore that much

 

[Dick Sirloin]

Ashes Against the Grain

Officially my favorite Agalloch now

 

[Dick Sirloin]

Townsend:

1. Ocean Machine
2. Accelerated Evolution
3. Terria
4. City
5. Ziltoid The Omniscient
6. Infinity (+4)
7. Deconstruction
8. Epicloud(er)
9. Synchestra
10. Addicted!
11. Ass-Sordid Demos
12. Ghost
13. Alien
14. The New Black
15. Ki
16. Physicist
17. Ass-Sordid Demos II
18. Hummer
19. Devlab
20. Cooked On Phonics
21. Heavy As A Really Heavy Thing
22. SYL

 

[NAD]

The Mantle
The White
Tomorrow Will Never Come
Pale Folklore
Faustian Echoes
Of Stone, Wind, and Pillor
Ashes Against the Grain
The Grey
/ Nest
Marrow of the Spirit

 

[NAD]

Larks' Tongues in Aspic
The Power to Believe
Starless and Bible Black
Lizard
Red
In the Court of the Crimson King
Discipline
The ConstruKction of Light
In the Wake of Poseidon
THRAK
Beat
Three of a Perfect Pair

 

[NAD]

Fluke
Headworm
Vermiculatus
Born With Teeth

 

[einride]

ok well

pale folklore
[...] (imagine this is about ten million miles of empty space)
the mantle
of stone, wind and pillor
marrow of the spirit
ashes against the grain
from which of this oak
faustian echoes
the white ep
the grey ep


i don't care to rank the nest split or the tomorrow 7" because honestly, how do you even remotely compare those to full-lengths

 

[ChaosLee]

Sin after Sin
Screaming for Vengeance
Stained Class
Defenders of the Faith
Sad Wings of Destiny
Painkiller
Point of Entry
British Steel
Rocka Rolla
Jugulator
Ram It Down
Turbo
Angel of Retribution
Nostradmus
.
.
.
Demolition

 

[NAD]

I am greatly moved by the song Tomorrow Will Never Come, that's why I rank that particular one so high.

I only skipped From Which of This Oak because it's a demo, but that's probably right above Faustian Echoes.

Honestly I love all their material pretty equally. But I haven't spent enough time with Marrow of the Spirit.

 

[Hell Mike]

Under a Funeral Moon
Panzerfaust
A Blaze in the Northern Sky
Transilvanian Hunger
Total Death
Soulside Journey
Goatlord
Dark Thrones and Black Flags
The Cult Is Alive
Plaguewielder
Ravishing Grimness
F.O.A.D.
Circle the Wagons
The Underground Resistance
Hate Them
Sardonic Wrath

All of the above are better than almost everything everyone else ever made. And I might have gotten all of the above except the all of the above-part wrong.

 

[Dick Sirloin]

Selling England By The Pound 10/10
Foxtrot 9.5/10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway 9.5/10
Nursery Cryme 8.5/10
Trespass 8.5/10
A Trick Of The Tail 8.5/10
Wind And Wuthering 8/10
Invisible Touch 8/10
Abacab 7.5/10
Duke 7.5/10
We Can’t Dance 7.5/10
…And Then There Were Three… 7/10
From Genesis To Revelation 6/10
Genesis 6/10

 

[Dick Sirloin]

GENESIS:

Selling England By the Pound
Foxtrot
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
A Trick of the Tail
Nursery Cryme
Trespass
Wind and Wuthering
Abacab
Duke
s/t
And Then There Were Three
Invisible Touch
From Genesis to Revelation
We Can't Dance
Calling All Stations

Wait....

 

[J.]

1. Graveland - Following the Voice of Blood

.....the rest of black metal