Would be nice to hear from the topic starter which reverb he finally went with.
After all the Valhalla praise I tried them all again. And I must admit that - although I still really like PSPs EasyVerb and 2445 - Valhalla VintageVerb's "Drum Plate" preset is perhaps the best snare verb I ever had. With just a little high- and lowcut before the verb it sounds just perfect!