Royal Carnage Top 64 CDs of 2000s - Round 1 Results

[Crimson Velvet]

Yeah, I listened to that Gojira thinking it would be some great death/thrash experience, but was hugely disappointed. There was a cool atmosphere in the first track, but it got old fast.

 

[lurch70]

There was a cool atmosphere

you people and your atmosphere ...

is this a metal board or some little girl convention?

[dontknowwhatemoticontouse]

 

[Demonspell]

Haha, when I saw that this album got 3 votes, first thing I did was check back to see who the 3 were. Seriously, fucking AWFUL album.

I'm also very surprised that the equally despised Dimmu managed to get eight votes, likely on account of the fact it's competition also gets slagged quite a bit.

 

[J.]

atmosphere

oh c'mon lurch, even slayer has an atmospheric vibe in their music. it's angry and unrelenting with a dab of the gayman butt sex

atmosphere doesn't mean keyboards or wind blowing through trees

 

[NAD]

neal also voted for Drudkh over Tool, which really surprised me tbh. I thought he was a tool. fan.

'kin brilliant.

Thank God Gojira and Slayer are out ...

'kin HILARIOUS.

 

[neal]

i think my feelings are hurt....i also cant believe i voted for in flames over dickinson's latest solo album, as i havent really heard either one...? i cant remember why i did that....either way.....fuck em both. and you.

 

[General Zod]

is this a metal board or some little girl convention?

LOL.

[dontknowwhatemoticontouse]

LOLx2.

Zod

 

[Crimson Velvet]

is this a metal board or some little girl convention?

So says one of the more prominent care-crew members!




or are you? I forget things easily.

 

[General Zod]

Less than 5 votes.... Iced Earth = 2

I thought you loved the trilogy. Why no vote on this one?

Zod

 

[JayKeeley]

I thought you loved the trilogy. Why no vote on this one?

Zod

Trilogy is probably the best thing IE have ever done. However, the "disc 1" isn't that good at all. (Or certainly not as good as Dark Saga, Something Wicked, or even Horror Show). Blut Aus Nord is excellent, creepy stuff so I declared the matchup a tie.

 

[lurch70]

So says one of the more prominent care-crew members!




or are you? I forget things easily.

I am the f'in leader ...

 

[General Zod]

...so I declared the matchup a tie.

This statement is either gay or lying, and possibly both. Actually, I need to hear that BAS.

Zod

 

[JayKeeley]

It goes like this:

Gettysburg Trilogy > The Work which Transforms God > Glorious Burden

 

[General Zod]

Gettysburg Trilogy > The Work which Transforms God > Glorious Burden

Mathmatically speaking, what are the odds I'd like "Transforms God"?

Zod

 

[JayKeeley]

Mathmatically speaking, what are the odds I'd like "Transforms God"?

Normally I'd say there's a 0.17% chance of you liking Blut Aus Nord, but catching it in the right mood, plus knowing that both J and Erik hate it, might elevate those chances to 0.18%.

 

[Nico]

Erik and J. only hate TWWTG, I'm sure they'd thoroughly enjoy the earlier albums.

[/hasmadethispointthousandsoftimes]

 

[lurch70]

Mathmatically speaking, what are the odds I'd like "Transforms God"?

Zod

i have a feeling you might like it ... it's not a conventional BM disc.

 

[MadeInNewJersey]

what in the fuck is going on around here? you go away for 5 days and looks what happens.

 

[General Zod]

what in the fuck is going on around here? you go away for 5 days and looks what happens.

To what exactly do you refer? Maiden nearly getting taken out in the first round? Thyrfing get shit-hammered? Or one too many polls being posted?

Zod

 

[JayKeeley]

Or the Ace Frehley vs. Rob Darken analogy!