Rush Vs Pink Floyd

[Silentjohan]

Pink Floyd
...yes indeed; one of the easiest polls ever..

 

[Ecstatic Youth]

Pink Floyd all the way
They are great.
I only like a select few Rsh songs.

and yes, Geddy Lee's voice can get annoying at times.

If you don't know Rush and ya hear 'em, you'll think it is a guy who sounds like a chick or a chick who sounds kinda man-ish.

 

[Brooks]

Rush = Hemispheres, 2112, Moving Pictures

Pink Floyd = Piper At The Gates of Dawn, Dark Side of the Moon, Meddle, Animals, WISH YOU WERE FUCKING HERE, The Wall...

More people "woke up" to Pink Floyd than just about any other band. I vote them.

 

[clayman666]

Id say Pink Floyd......alot would depend on if your stoned or not

 

[Thorns of Sorrow]

Originally posted by Demonspell
Two completely different bands that cannot reasonably be compared in anything but a popularity contest...I did not vote.

agreed

 

[quilmes]

Rush all the way

 

[City of the Moon]

I like both bands, but I like Rush more.

 

[golgotha85]

I like a lot of Rush songs, but same deal with Pink Floyd

 

[Feanor IV]

Floyd, without a question or a doubt. Floyd are top in their genre, and I'm not so much into Rush, so...

I'd think about it more, if the poll was between Floyd and King Crimson!

 

[Prophetix]

Both are extremely great bands. However, I tend to choose Rush over Floyd. Rush practically singlehandedly broke new ground in prog-rock music and paved the way for all progressive metal! They both shape great influencial greatness on metal bands today. But honestly the new Pink Floyd era without Roger Waters was greatly uninfluenced and mainstream-friendly. Ofcourse there are a few good songs here and there but nothing compared to the mind-provoking psychadellic Waters-era..
Rush gets my vote.

 

[Punisher]

Originally posted by Demonspell
Two completely different bands that cannot reasonably be compared in anything but a popularity contest...I did not vote.

i didn't ask you to compare i asked which band you like more.

 

[ricochet]

Floyd

 

[dolphz]

I expected more from the people on the board. Whiny and whimpy Pink Floyd over the dominating Rush by a more than two to one margin???? Why??