Aaron Smith
Envisage Audio
You're putting words in my mouth, dude. You are making arguments with me based off of things that I didn't even say.
I said absolutely nothing about the war being right.
The "newly freed Iraqis" phrase I used was not a reflection of the freedom that I have in the United States. Of course the Iraqis aren't happy with the mess that their country is in at the moment, but other than the minority Sunnis whom Saddam cared for, I don't think that many Iraqis at all would opt to take Saddam back and live like that again, instead of just sticking it out and establishing stability without Saddam. And I agree with everything you said about the US being an experiment, a baby country, whatever you want to call it. We are too young to boss around other civilizations, and probably even an old country still shouldn't be bossing around another civilization.
Of course the US instigated the war, but even if we packed up and left Iraq today, I wouldn't expect the sectarian violence to stop. Yes, we went in there and started the whole mess, but most of the violence is Iraqis fighting Iraqis who have differing opinions about how the new government should be built.
Again, I didn't say that.
...So should we go topple them too?
I said absolutely nothing about the war being right.
Newly freed? That's the epitome of American arrogance.
The "newly freed Iraqis" phrase I used was not a reflection of the freedom that I have in the United States. Of course the Iraqis aren't happy with the mess that their country is in at the moment, but other than the minority Sunnis whom Saddam cared for, I don't think that many Iraqis at all would opt to take Saddam back and live like that again, instead of just sticking it out and establishing stability without Saddam. And I agree with everything you said about the US being an experiment, a baby country, whatever you want to call it. We are too young to boss around other civilizations, and probably even an old country still shouldn't be bossing around another civilization.
It'd be one thing if the Iraqis had done this all on their own (a la the French Revolution), but they didn't. We did. Shameful.
Of course the US instigated the war, but even if we packed up and left Iraq today, I wouldn't expect the sectarian violence to stop. Yes, we went in there and started the whole mess, but most of the violence is Iraqis fighting Iraqis who have differing opinions about how the new government should be built.
It's also extremely arrogant to think that this is what Iraq needs to become like us...
Again, I didn't say that.
