Btw, I took that step from a cubicle-style job to freedom a few years ago. That's why I know how hard it is
Thanks for your feedback, and no, I wasn't offended.
I can't say I completely disagree with you on a lot of levels. I don't think GearGoblin is particularly original, but it is useful. But I also don't think Google or Craigslist or MySpace were particularly original either. After all, there already were tons of big search engines, there were tons of online classifieds, and there was Friendster.
Sometimes it's not about having some bold new idea, it's about doing something ordinary in a new and better way. With GearGoblin, my goal is to bring back more of the "classic" eBay simplicity and reasonable listing fees with a few useful Web 2.0 features thrown in, targeted at the music instruments niche. Since I'm well connected in the music community in general, I feel that I have the ability to bring in some early adopters to battle-test and evangelize the platform, and that I can scale the user base from there.
I don't think it requires a huge budget to start something successful, and plenty of big companies invest millions into failed ventures all the time. At the end of the day there are a lot of other factors to what makes a website succeed or fail, and budget has never been the big reason in either case.
Congrats on escaping the cubicle farm. It hasn't been easy for me, either, and I'm never going to put too much emotional stock into the success or failure of my ventures. It all comes down to the
fail-fast approach.
Thanks to everyone for your feedback and enthusiasm!