Starting a new label in this age of freebie downloading is madness to be fair (which is why I've just started a new one
). It's basically a huge gamble and, like all gambling, don't play with money you can't afford to lose.
I don't really have time to go into the ins and outs of it all, but here's a checklist of the important stuff:
1)
Distribution. Distribution is the main issue for any new label. Unfortunately you're not going to get any attention from the major indie distributors in any country unless you've already got 15+ releases under your belt and a commitment (and budget) to advertise / promote your releases. You can spend $20k on an album, but if it's not available in the stores then you're throwing your money away.
There's a way around it though. Many small labels act as mail orders, trading their own CDs with CDs from other small labels. It's time consuming, but build a big enough sales base and you could find that the mail order side of things gets bigger than the label itself (see: The End Records & Laser / Sensory Records). There are also small wholesalers who may take some stock on a consignment basis (IE: they pay for what they sell. You give 'em 250 CDs to sell, they sell 50, you get 200 back, and usually at your own shipping cost).
2)
Money. Okay, so you may be able to pick up an album for free from a band who have self recorded or whatever. But there are quite a few other considerations. You have to pay a mechanical royalty on every CD you press (usually in advance). You will have to shell out for artwork, barcodes, mastering and pressing.
Advertising isn't cheap. A half page advert in even a smallish mag like Terrorizer is going to be around the $600 mark. Most labels also press between 500-1000 promo CDs per release 10 weeks in advance for the press. You then gotta get those CDs in the right hands. In the US you can pay upwards of $500 per release (plus postage and expenses) for a press / promotion guy. If you want Europe too then you have to consider at least one extra guy in the main territories like the UK, Germany and France.
There's also stuff like buying into chain store campaigns, tour support, videos (that no one plays), etc, that I won't get into right now.
3)
The bands themselves: You have to be realistic about what a band can achieve in the grand scheme of things. Where hundreds of labels fail at the first hurdle is when a well-meaning guy picks up a local band he's seen at a local bar and thinks they'll become superstars. That may well be the case, but if you don't have a good foundation to be able to get the band in the public eye then it's doomed to failure from the get go. Also, are the band known outside of their home town (20,000 plays on Myspace doesn't count)? Do they have ambition beyond pulling 200 folks at a local show? Will they get their arses on the road to promote the record (studio projects by rule of thumb sell half of what a touring band could expect to sell).
4)
No bullshit: Don't promise bands the world when you can't back it up with real life happenings. It seems obvious, but I've seen it 1000 times in the past.
Looking at it entirely from my own band's perspective: We have had some decent press including interviews in Kerrang, Metal Hammer, Metal Maniacs, Terrorizer, Zero Tolerence, etc. Decent advertising to back it up. We shot an expensive (looking!) video, have played with Dream Theater and toured the UK, have close to 300,000 Myspace plays, we gave away over 1000 demo CDs before we got signed, etc, etc. Total worldwide sales to date? About 4500. That includes the 350 or so we've sold direct via Myspace and at shows (we've sold more shirts than CDs on Myspace actually, maybe because you can't download a shirt for free?). 1800 of those sales are here in the UK which is undoubtedly our biggest market. The fact that our label is pretty happy with that return may tell you about the present state of the market right now. They recently released an album (I won't say who) that got great press, was advertised all over the place and still only sold 600 worldwide...
Like I say it's madness to try and start a label right now, but if you're confident in the bands you have signed, if you have enough contacts within the industry and you're sure you're in a position to be able to give it your best shot the don't let me stop you.
I'm off to drink more beer. I shall check back if anyone has any comments or questions.