Yeah, there's always something to be pissed off about even if you have it made in the shade.
They've shown that they can write kick ass METAL songs. I think they still could but find it harder to now and choose not too mainly for financial reasons.
Here's my theory:
I think it started with the black album that they just chose to lean more on the rock side in hopes of at least some commercial success and a bit more money. I'm guessing that they did slightly better than just getting by, which is still not nearly enough and were probably sick of the living poor lifestyle (who wouldn't be?).
So when they saw the massive success and money from the black album they needed to continue along that road going even more commercial rock oriented to (hope to) assure more of that good income (and to prove to themselves that they can do it) and they've continued to do so in order to maintain the lifestyle that anyone would want to have.
Otherwise they may have to sell a house and sports car.
Plus there are probably other factors involved like James's voice naturally changing from age and maybe hurting all the time from that vocal style and possibly getting bored with everything and wanting to prove that he can actually sing with melody and write classic heavy rock songs like he probably grew up on.
They obviously enjoy playing that rock style so it seems to be a win win situation for them and as for the hardcore fans of the old school Metallica... well, thats where I feel let down but what are going to do? They're not living their lives for us. Looking back, I can't blame them. With age comes maturity and responsibility. The brain chemistry changes, the fire may not remain as strong as it used to be (especially if you've accomplished everything that you set out to), the body changes (possible lack of energy, physical problems like back pain) and money is essential. Be poor your entire life or be set for life?
I wish they would go back to their thrash sound but if my theory above is true then I don't see that ever happening. Not seriously anyway.
Then again I look at Dave Mustaine who seems to be living rather well and still writes kick ass songs imo so I guess I just shot down that theory.
That's how I view Metallica though.
I shouldn't post this but I spent a lot of time on it so screw it. :Smug:
Someone should photoshop metallica to look like old men and post it to compliment the thread title.