Big fan of Tiles, as they were "local" back where I grew up in Detroit. Can't even begin to count how many times I have seen them live..... Definitely sounds like you caught them on an off-night, as they are normally very solid live.
"Fence the Clear" is my favorite disc of theirs, as it seems like every album since then tries to recapture what they did with that album. "Window Dressing"
was pretty flat, but I thought they rebounded nicely on "Fly Paper".
NP - Lord Divine "...in Disgrace"