Virtual Guitar: wich mix sounds better?

[Javi Perera]

Hi everybody!

I've made two mixes of the same song. The only things that change are the guitar and bass tone. But I dunno which one sounds better. What do you think, dudes an dudettes?

JAVI PERERA - MIX A

JAVI PERERA - MIX B

The poll begins... now!

 

[The Front Studio]

B isn't working :/
I love A, though

 

[Javi Perera]

My bad! Link fixed!

Sorry, sorry, sorry

 

[Javi Perera]

Anybody votes?

 

[Erik Monsonis]

B for sure

 

[SteelRat]

I like B as well...

 

[Javi Perera]

Hmmm, the guitar on "B" sounds darker, doesn't it?

 

[MattG]

B!

 

[Erik Monsonis]

Yeah, it's a bit darker, but it's what the song needs

 

[The Front Studio]

B for sure

 

[Javi Perera]

100% B.... Just.... Wow.... :S

 

[Dexter_prog]

B fo shizzle, guitarras sound fatter, though A sounds good to.

 

[Erik Monsonis]

100% B.... Just.... Wow.... :S

Are you trying to say that you think A is better? No way man

 

[Tokyurot]

The guitars in B were more friendly to ears here, but they could use just abit more highend, not as much as in A though.
If you had set the LP abit lower in A it might have won as well

 

[shogger]

Yeah, the best would be in the middle between both of them. If I had to decide I would take A because of it's rawness. I like the more modern B too though. Both versions do sound really good and I like the mixes overall!

Shogger

 

[The-Zeronaut]

i like B

 

[Harry Hughes]

B.
Definitely needs a little more 6Khz though, just a tiny bit.

 

[Javi Perera]

Hmm, I'm thinking on uploading the raw files and making a "Mix/master contest" of this song