What if Anders and Mikael switched places again?

[FJChaos]

What would DT and IF be like?
Would IF improve?
Would DT turn to shit?

 

[waif]

It would be awful all around. Both bands would be much worse. But at least it would get you faggots to admit that Anders' vocals do fit the music.

 

[TrickySkittles]

Dumbest thread ever, if you can't answer that yourself you're a moron. You switch the two and there is no cohesion in either band. Maybe if this was 10-13 years ago when the similarities were more noticable you could talk about this, but the bands have gone in different directions
.

 

[FJChaos]

It would be awful all around. Both bands would be much worse. But at least it would get you faggots to admit that Anders' vocals do fit the music.

His vocals are good. But, Mikael would be interesting for live performances. Imagine him doing old songs like Moonshield, Worlds Within Margin, Zombie Inc., and Dead Eternity.

Dumbest thread ever, if you can't answer that yourself you're a moron. You switch the two and there is no cohesion in either band. Maybe if this was 10-13 years ago when the similarities were more noticable you could talk about this, but the bands have gone in different directions
.

I was just saying "what if?". I wanted to see your opinion.

 

[DE4life]

In Flames would have to change back to their old school sound to accomodate Stanne, whilst DT would have to create a totally new sound to fit Anders into their music. Definately wouldn't work.

 

[waif]

Stanne would not be interesting live at all, because he wouldn't work for anything past subterranean. In case you've noticed, he does rasps, not growls. He could maybe handle the stuff on Jester simply by virtue of being awesome, but definitely not Whoracle.