I'm not your friend and i suspect no one is here nor offline... i stand by my comments as well... and most would agree with me about you in general... :Smug:
Who was better: Stevie Ray Vaughan or Jimi Hendrix?
- Thread starter The Ozzman
- Start date
Einherjar86
Active Member
we'll dont wet ur pants neither sweetpea... :Smug:Oh stop, your whurting my feelings
mdmatt4ever
Member
- Sep 27, 2006
- 2,742
- 23
- 38
anyways this thread need to die but to answer the question.
who wrote better songs?hendrix
who was more inventive with the guitar?hendrix
who played with the most passion? tie
who played with better technique and tone? SRV
take from that what you will. does that answer who the best guitar player is? no because jeff beck craps on both of them
who wrote better songs?hendrix
who was more inventive with the guitar?hendrix
who played with the most passion? tie
who played with better technique and tone? SRV
take from that what you will. does that answer who the best guitar player is? no because jeff beck craps on both of them
Einherjar86
Active Member
mdmatt4ever
Member
- Sep 27, 2006
- 2,742
- 23
- 38
well everyone has a differnt opinion so it doesn't matter. i'd say the 10 best guitar players are in order:
1 jeff beck
2 jimi hendrix
3 eric clapton
4 jimmy page
5 SRV
6 duane allman
7 eddie van halen
8 steve vai
9 joe satriani
10 vernon reid
10 best drummers ever:
1 buddy rich
2 vinnie colaiuta
3 terry bozzio
4 ginger baker
5 mike mangini
6 aynsley dunbar
7 cozy powell
8 carmine appice
9 neil peart
10 john bonham
Beck is in a weague of his own. I have a cover of Beck and Seal doing Manic Depression and it just doesnt have the fire in the guitar playing that Hendrix had. They did an interesting version, none the less. Also a live performance with Beck and Vaughan reveil Vaughan a richer player. Still the Beck thing is unique.
Einherjar86
Active Member
I think he was trying to imply a sarcastic whiny tone to his post. As in "awww, did I whurt duh widdul baby's feeewings?"
But then again, it's razor; he doesn't own a dictionary. And honestly I don't know why you would put a "w" at the beginning of "hurt" to get that sound.
And mdmatt4ever, you left David Gilmour off your list.
EDIT: @Ozz; and he just did it again with the word "league."
But then again, it's razor; he doesn't own a dictionary. And honestly I don't know why you would put a "w" at the beginning of "hurt" to get that sound.
And mdmatt4ever, you left David Gilmour off your list.
EDIT: @Ozz; and he just did it again with the word "league."
mdmatt4ever
Member
- Sep 27, 2006
- 2,742
- 23
- 38
Einherjar86
Active Member
Okay. Gilmour's my favorite of all time. I prefer taste over speed. No one can say as much as Gilmour in so few notes.
I prefer expression myself but many faster players have said plenty as well. There is alot of great improv done over the years. I wouldnt say "No one" can as Gilmour because you have Santana, Gary Moore as well as many quick players that have their share of heart bleeding solos.
[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uJXa0mOc1pk&feature=related[/ame]
[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uJXa0mOc1pk&feature=related[/ame]
Last edited by a moderator:
Belligerent
Greekus Urungus
Last edited by a moderator:
BloodSword
Member
Simply put, David Gilmour, is one of the most superb guitarists(musicians) of our time. I always thought he was the most talented band member of Floyd. His guitar playing and tone are spectacular. Now, I'm not stating a comparison, when I say, Andrew Latimer(Camel) is another guitarist, often overlooked, that plays beautifully. Has anyone heard the 2cd and 2dvd package called "Live in Gdansk" by Mr.Gilmour?
Einherjar86
Active Member
Of definitely, Gary Moore is a very soulful player as well. Santana is good, but not one of my favorites. In essence, I just think that Gilmour is the epitome of the slow, melodic emotional player. Others do it too, but Gilmour always does it and nails it every time.
Most definitely, I bought On An Island the day it came out. Gilmour's older solo records are good too. He's really a top-notch musician, and a superb songwriter.
The Gilmour vs. Waters debate is tough for me because I love both of them equally. They each do their own thing so well. Together they created possibly the greatest sound in rock history (in my opinion, of course; Floyd's my favorite band
).
Belligerent
Greekus Urungus
Floyd have surpassed Zeppelin for me (as far as favorite classic rock band). I think Gilmour is more talented than Waters yes, but a close call indeed.
Similar threads
