In the ultimate setlist thread, both of these songs were mentioned alot- just wondering which is the better song.. and yes - Parts 1 and 2 for Winter's Dream
A Winter's Dream vs. Candlight Fantasia
- Thread starter urinalcakemix
- Start date
ProgMetalFan
In the attic
The Yngster
Member
Ultimate_Symphony
Rusted Angel
- Jul 18, 2002
- 4,411
- 217
- 63
Knight of the Templar
PEAC EOUT!!
Looks like we're losing... yep, my vote was for "A Winter's Dream". Why? Well... I don't know, really... but it's just... different. It was a hard decision, though, but I guess I just like more "A Winter's Dream".
And I'm not saying that "AWD" is better than "CF"... it's just... a matter of tastes
.
And I'm not saying that "AWD" is better than "CF"... it's just... a matter of tastes
.
The Yngster
Member
BastrdDrmr
Member
Zax666
The Prince Of Ice. Almost
SilentRealm
Member
ehh candlelight.. im not overly fond of either song, but my only real reason for not liking candlelight is the fact its really..ermm..sappy? that doesnt make it bad though, just not really my taste.. whereas winters dream I dont think is a very good song.
FLechdrop
Member
The Metal Chick
In the Dragon's Den
I chose Candelight because I love that heavy part in the middle...PLAAAYYY THE VIOLENT STRIIINGS OOOOOF MY SYYYMMPHOOONYYY!!!
Prismatic Sphere
We Carouse
"A Winter's Dream"
CLEARLY their most criminally underrated song in their entire catalog by this message board.
FYI, Winter's Dream is my 2nd fav SX song and Candlelight is my 3rd. Winter has a pretty damn clear lead though.
CLEARLY their most criminally underrated song in their entire catalog by this message board.
FYI, Winter's Dream is my 2nd fav SX song and Candlelight is my 3rd. Winter has a pretty damn clear lead though.
Serge...
That guy you're not
Candlelight Fantasia. That song just gets better and better as it goes on. And anyway, I never liked A Winter's Dream too much.
korruption
Amateur Dentist
MorphineChild205
Lt. Horatio Caine
Candlelight Fantasia.
There's elements of this song which I absolutely love, like what P is doing in the verses and the heavy middle interlude section. And Russell's voice is (of course) amazing on this song.
A Winter's Dream is (to me) the 2nd best song on The Damnation Game. However, CF clearly stands out above it in my book.
There's elements of this song which I absolutely love, like what P is doing in the verses and the heavy middle interlude section. And Russell's voice is (of course) amazing on this song.
A Winter's Dream is (to me) the 2nd best song on The Damnation Game. However, CF clearly stands out above it in my book.
Demonspell
cheating the polygraph
I voted for Candelight Fantasia because I find it to be highly emotional and the keyboard sounds are excellent, but I agree that Winter's Dream is one of the most underrated songs in the SX catalogue...and part two has the coolest riff on its album.
R*O*C*K*S*
Member
ILOVE A Winter's Dream
but I have to go with Candlelight Fantasia
that's a terrible shame, the whole album The Damnation Game is extremely underrated and it has GREAT tunes on it
but I have to go with Candlelight Fantasia
that's a terrible shame, the whole album The Damnation Game is extremely underrated and it has GREAT tunes on it
Caelestia
rawr
Candlelight Fantasia.
I love the song and it brings back memories for me, although not necessarily great.
I love the song and it brings back memories for me, although not necessarily great.
korruption
Amateur Dentist
As it's my favourite Symphony X album, I have to agree. It's fucking criminal!R*O*C*K*S* said:ILOVE A Winter's Dream
but I have to go with Candlelight Fantasia
that's a terrible shame, the whole album The Damnation Game is extremely underrated and it has GREAT tunes on it
Similar threads
