I prefer PH's video.
What I don't like of both videos (including the one for TGC) are the lack of sense and concept. A lot of images and things but they don't connect with one concept or anything at all, which is weird since opeth lyric's are full of ideas and this isn't a band that lacks of concept.
I just can't connect those videos with the songs or with opeth. I don't think that the gothic thing has anything to do with opeth at all. Sure it is dark music and whatever, but is not about gothic chicks or things like that.
Sure if this were lacuna coil it would fit, but it isn't, and I don't see any relation at all.
If you mute the music you get a good looking video, still it doesn't have sense, but all the aesthetic thing is good, now, with the music I don't get it.