It's circular reasoning, Louisville was good until Rutgers beat them but because they aren't a dynasty team (read: SEC team, Notre Dame, Cal, or USC), no one respects them. If they beat West Virginia also, it will only further prove the weakness of the Big East, because if Rutgers can come out of nowhere and beat you, your team must have not been that good to begin with, regardless of record or quality of play, including the national ranking of your defense (2nd), possession of two eventual first rounders on offense, including a potential darkhorse Heisman candidate (Leonard and Rice), or an undefeated record. However, I won't get too fat ahead of myself. Rutgers still needs to win out, including that game in Morgantown before any of these complaints become legitimate.
Wisconsin should get a look, isn't their one loss to Michigan, with a win over PSU?