Look, no one is pretending this is more metaul than the latest release by Nun Impalement or more progressive than Hexagonal Chromosphere's newest. It's a fascination with one of the iconic figures in the genre, and seeing them pull something off that's even remotely entertaining is sort of like seeing the Cubs make the playoffs or something. They're old, they're grizzled, they're washed up, basically everyone hates them, but it looks like there's still a flicker of life in there somewhere and a lot of us are very curious to hear what they can do and will be pleased on some level if they succeed in any way in making a halfway decent album. This makes anything they release far more interesting to us than superior releases by no-name bands. It's not just about the music. This is why all the "boo this sucks go listen to Testament" talk is so tiresome, I couldn't care less about this genre, much less Testament, I'm simply interested cause it's Metallica and it's like following some ongoing sordid reality show or something. I used to adore them, and thus follow all their releases with some interest.