Dig Bloodbath. Where next?

Did someone say alcohol?

I'm not sure what era Bloodbath you listened to J-Mac. Personally my favourite by them is Nightmare Made Flesh which was their second album and in my opinon the most consistently awesome. But their first album Resurrection through Carnage is pretty sweet too and has that old-school dirtier sound going on. The albums after that have higher production and a cleaner sound overall. If you're looking for that old school sound everything these guys suggested is good, it's more of a niche sound so it requires a bit of digging. If you just want some quality Death Metal there is a huge variety to choose from (the Death Metal bands thread has lots of good recommendations there)
The Fathomless Mastery is my favourite, closely followed by Nightmares.