Funniest thing ever .. probably

Does the second word "metal" mean anything to you or suggest the possibility that it is connected to a specific genre of music?

okay, lets overanalyze this:

BLACK

that's the satan part

METAL

that's the music part

SATAN METAL = BLACK METAL

that wasn't so hard, now was it?
 
JayKeeley said:
Deicide is black metal!!! :loco:
Dont forget about Possessed!


Also:
If a band has satanic lyrics and plays music influenced by Helloween, the band plays black metal?
And:
A band plays music influenced by early Bathory, early Satyricon etc, but doesnt have black metal lyrics. The band with the Helloween influences is black metal, and this band is not?
Grim answers appreciated
 
Erik's interview with Fenriz said:
MERCYFUL FATE "Evil" -- I take it you subscribe to the opinion that Mercyful Fate is in fact a black metal band despite their musical differences to stuff like BATHORY or SODOM, then?

F: No, it's not BLACK and white - it never was in the 80s. one just reached out for the darkest metal there was, and when asked about what this style should be called, it was natural to call it BLACK METAL. The compilation is also VERY true to what we Norwegians listened to and were inspired by in the early 90s, but we also listened to WHEN "the black death" or DIAMANDA GALAS for inspiration. Or MUNCH or CHRISTIAN DEATH..
.
 
Some people like the late Euronymous would tell you that Deicide and Mercyful Fate is indeed black metal, as they think that metal + satan = black metal, but I personally am not prepared to go that far. For me to call something black metal, it needs to have the ideology, plus it needs to have some sort of discernible similarity to the founding black metal bands like Bathory, Hellhammer, Mayhem...
 
Coven [70s]
Witchcraft Destroys Minds And Reaps Souls (1969)
fe_11415.jpg
 
The idea of Black Metal is threefold:

one idea you're beginning to get a grasp on: The fact that black metal is metal about satan.

The second idea is that black metal is a certain style of metal.

The third point ties into the first point which is that black metal had ideology. It is not merely a musicial style but an amalgamation of style and ideology. You can have the style without the ideology, or the ideology without the style, but without both it cannot be defined as black metal.