GMD Poll: Top Ten Albums Of 1988
- Thread starter no country for old wainds
- Start date
CiG
Aaaaaaaah!
TechnicalBarbarity
-TheNightsBane-
Yeah man, i love Violent Restitution. Bonafide thrash metal classic right there.
Haven't listened to that Incubus album in years though, maybe i should have given it another shot before voting but i dont even see it beating out some of the stuff in my HM list. Best year we've done so far imo.
Baroque
Active Member
Incubus made my HM, I meant to include Razor as well but had no room in the top 10 for them. In a different year they would have made it, like 2009.
Krow
Garbage Connoisseur
RedinTheSky
Member
-CC-
Something in My Eye
- Jan 12, 2009
- 3,967
- 799
- 113
You seem to be forgetting about the upcoming GMD Poll: Top Ten Albums of 2003...
EDIT: That joke would have worked better if we hadn't actually done that year.
Serjeant Grumbles
Active Member
- Mar 20, 2005
- 4,380
- 2,872
- 113
I'm disappointed that Thundersteel didn't make it to the top ten so you could feature a quote referencing Voldemort-in-a-tank cover art.
- Nov 23, 2002
- 26,565
- 9,580
- 113
i'm disappointed 'cause it's badass! it was my #11 though so i can't complain really.
i thought "them" was the surprise package actually, wasn't on my radar for making the top ten at all.
i thought "them" was the surprise package actually, wasn't on my radar for making the top ten at all.
Satanstoenail
My Larpstyle determines my Derpstyle
Baroque
Active Member
Only two albums I voted for made the top 10 (1 and 2). And I'm not even disappointed in the results. This year could have easily been a top 20 with no loss in quality
Baroque
Active Member
HamburgerBoy
Active Member
- Sep 16, 2007
- 15,042
- 4,848
- 113
Irae Melanox is one of the albums the in-crowders get right. Kerrang apparently called it a thrash album back in the day anyways and it's faster than South of Heaven so yeah there's objectively no reason to prefer Slayer for this year.
TechnicalBarbarity
-TheNightsBane-
not a bad album by any means, but its easily the second weakest album up there and shouldn't have even made the top ten in such great year imo. And no, its not better then South of Heaven. Nothing on that album touches Silent Scream, Ghosts of War, Cleanse the Soul , Live Undead, Behind the Crooked Cross, the title track. Man, that album would have been near flawless if it wasn't for Mandatory Suicide and Read Between the Lines
CiG
Aaaaaaaah!
Master_Yoda77
Juggalo
Definitely the worst of Metallica's 4 good albums.
crimsonfloyd
Active Member
Whoa, EXCEPT Mandatory Suicide? That's one of the best songs on war, period.
As far as a direct comparison between Irae Melanox vs. South of Heaven, it seems a little useless. I prefer the later slightly, but both are great representations of their respective styles. Considering the style of IM is far from what you like, hearing you complain about it ranking 4 rings a little empty.
HamburgerBoy
Active Member
- Sep 16, 2007
- 15,042
- 4,848
- 113
Mandatory Suicide gets a bit chuggy and goofy, not bad but probably the weakest song, cover aside.
TechnicalBarbarity
-TheNightsBane-
its a perfectly fine comparison, they don't need to play the exact same type of music for one to say one album is better than the other. The songs on album A are stronger than the songs on album B. Regardless of style or what not. And i think HBB kind of explained why he made the "direct comparison"
How in the world is it "far from what i like"? I enjoy the album and im almost almost sure ive listened to it dozens of times more than you have ... so i would think my opinion/"complaint" on them is infinitely more valid than yours.
Lmao! No, it is not. It's one of Slayers worst songs from their godly albums.
crimsonfloyd
Active Member
Yeah, you can compare any album ever recorded in any style in that way. That's not saying much.
As for what HBB said, I don't know as I rarely read his posts. Going back and reading it now, his argument seems to be that one magazine incorrectly identified them as fast back in the day, and that one is faster than the other. Pretty weak justification for a comp, by any rational standard.
You rarely like power or progresive metal from what I've seen. So, yes it is kind of a surprise to hear you list to the album.
I'm not really interested in having an unverifiable debate about how many times you've heard the album. Childish pissing contest shit.
That said, the premise of your argument is massively flawed. Most albums can be thoroughly analyzed and grasped within 10-12 listens by most people. After that, there's diminishing returns on what new findigd one "gets" out of relistening to the album. Therefore, the validity of the opinion of someone who has listened to the 10 times and someone who has listened to the album 40 times is negligible.
It's high art.
Similar threads
