Considering how nobody said Still Life, I will go with BWP. It is a very fine choice, and was also my introduction to Opeth because I didnt give MAYH a chance at the time yet. This guy's a musician, so I'm pretty sure he will have a more instant appretiation for Opeth's music than others I've showed Opeth to.
BWP is indeed a good choice tho. The Leper Affinity is very headbangable, Bleak is very everything, Harvest has an awesome chorus, and The Drapery Falls has something everyone can love. I didnt go past track 4 for months. Those tracks alone did the trick.
Making a mix is a good idea. However, I think I'm already smothering the guy cuz I'm burning 2 Devin Townsend cds along with them.
He gets:
Opeth- BWP
Opeth- Damnation
Devin Townsend- Synchestra
Devin Townsend- Ocean Machine
He's getting hooked up. I wish people would introduce me to good shit like this.