haven't played any of those games lol
i don't play video games alot, i only use my ps2 for a DVD player for my bedroom lol, but when i get bored i'll turn it on
my all time favorite is the mod Rocket Arena 2 for Quake 2
close comers: RUNE (this game owns), undying, system shock 2, unreal 1 sp, doom3 (two weeks of play and i already mention it as a favorite haha)
Well... out of that list, i'd have to say Skies Of Arcadia, but in all, the bet games ever are Xenogears, Xensaga, Suikoden I, II, and III, and of course, Final Fantasy VII, VIII, and Tales Of Symphonia.
out of that list diablo 2 - but my comp couldnt handle movies or online play.
and the ps2 is out of the question, it doesnt play cd's (and i had to be one of the first to have one - dont ever be the first with consoles!)
Mine is The Suffering. That game scared the shit out of me, dude. Like, there was always shit jumping out at you from out of nowhere. And some of that shit was pretty bloody. But it kicked ass. UT2K4 kicked ass too. I had a lot of fun using codes to get weird ass weapons, like a cattle prod and a paintball gun. That was some fun shit.