wishtheend
clip the apex
This is for use on a polyphonic instrument - not multiple instrument tracks. You would use this on just a piano track, or just a guitar track. It can not be used to separate complete stereo mixes.
Melodyne Direct Note Access - !!!!!!!!
- Thread starter Ben Johnson
- Start date
slashvanyoung
Dopefish lives!
Yes, yes... we all know. We're just wondering what would turn out IF we would use it on a multiple instrument track.
Torniojaws
They call me Juha
Well, give it 10 - 20 years and that will happen. The human brain is fairly able to separate each instrument in a mix, though not perfectly. So it's only a matter of properly modelling the human brain musical function. In the end, the brain is nothing more than a regular micro controller, albeit a lot more powerful than man-made devices (so far). With nanotechnology coming to the doorstep, we'll take a huge leap towards a perfect human brain modelling capability - and perhaps even beyond.
So it looks like if you buy version 1 now for 299, you get a free upgrade to version 2 in the fall, which will be 399.
DivisionByZero
Gold Member
This is insane.
Ok, there might be cases where it works worse than for a piano, an acoustic guitar or a pop singer, but still...
But to be honest, I don't see any evil here. Why should it be wrong to enhance a recorded performance? People are right when they say, that the musical skill gets less and less important the better technology gets, but that's true since the advent of multitrackers and overdubbing. At the end of the day the result is the important thing for me. And if I listen to a great song I don't care if the guitar part has been recorded 127 times or just twice and 'melodyned' afterwards.
Ok, there might be cases where it works worse than for a piano, an acoustic guitar or a pop singer, but still...
But to be honest, I don't see any evil here. Why should it be wrong to enhance a recorded performance? People are right when they say, that the musical skill gets less and less important the better technology gets, but that's true since the advent of multitrackers and overdubbing. At the end of the day the result is the important thing for me. And if I listen to a great song I don't care if the guitar part has been recorded 127 times or just twice and 'melodyned' afterwards.
Aaron Smith
Envisage Audio
That's basically how I feel. If someone without the talent is made to sound like they do have the talent, it will be them who looks like an ass when they try to reproduce it on stage and can't do it. No one is going to blame the recording engineer! I would much rather use my time as efficiently as possible in the studio and have my focus set on the final product. If you want to put the blame on someone for the downfall of musical integrity or whatever you want to call it, the blame lies on the big record company executives for creating the modern pop star.
MetalJonesy
more metal, more booze!!!
This is definitely revolutionary, but I don't think it has much more potential for 'evil' usage than midi. We've been able to move late snare beats and edit the dynamics of already played piano parts using midi since the early 80's.
As long as live performances continue to exist, I wouldn't care how good the technology gets (as long we don't get to the point of nuking each other with entry-level editions of Cubase).
As long as live performances continue to exist, I wouldn't care how good the technology gets (as long we don't get to the point of nuking each other with entry-level editions of Cubase).
Gustavo_Loureiro
Member
- May 27, 2006
- 331
- 0
- 16
Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha, that reminds me of this (it's all funny, but I'm referring to the last part specifically)
I don't see any problem with the modern pop stars
In that case, you'd probably love the stuff in this thread
Gustavo_Loureiro
Member
- May 27, 2006
- 331
- 0
- 16
In that case, you'd probably love the stuff in this thread
Sure you can name some awful pop stars and I can name some great ones..
(hilarious video btw)
I thought there are some programs that separates track from a mixdown i think.Can melodyne make a midi sound real time what i can replace after?Like i play distortion guitars live, i split the guitar signal one signal goes to the amp, one to the pc->melodyne->accoustic guitar simulator, software synth .....?hm?
V
V
