None of the Immortal videos I have downloaded were live recordings, so they DO COUNT. Music videos aren't made simply because the band is more commercialized. They are meant to give their fans a glimpse of what they had in mind when making the song, most of the time. If they're just the band playing a song and they happened to have a professional film crew on hand (not a live performance, though), then the music video is to show what people who can't/don't go to their live gigs are missing out on. Most of the time...