dan weapon
Planet Smasher
I disagree, Wasn't it just Hetfield that wrote blackened???
Once Kirk started getting recording duties and input, and Lars started getting even more input the band went downhill...
Stop being pedantic (and entirely incorrect)
I'm pretty sure it was actually Hetfield, Ulrich and Newsted from memory... as far as I can recall Motorbreath was the only song that was credited with JUST Hetfield. And considering Hetfield/Ulrich wrote most of load and reload I'd say that THEY ARE THE SAME BAND.
And yes I agree with you, Metallica were better when Kirk wasn't allowed to play rhythm on record. But regardless of that fact, ...And Justice For All wasn't released as a hetfield solo record, so therefore I'm gonna stand by the fact that (bass players aside) Justice and St Anger were written by the same band, regardless of quality or who played what.
EDIT: If we're going to be super pedantic about it, hammett actually had 4 out of 9 songwriting credits on AJFA, and 6 out of 13 on Reload which works out as almost exactly the same percentage.