Need help on which CD to get (out of 3)

[Katatonic]

Morning-fucking-rise.

 

[ethereallights]

Where did I say I was being mean to my mom?

I just think all Mothers should be respected and all that jazz.... I'm not saying you, I'm just trying to use you to inspire others.

 

[xsjado]

Ah I see. And I do respect my mother.

 

[Demilich]

Pick up Still Life first man, perfect mix of accessibility and great songs.

 

[My Arms, Your Hearse]

Morningrise Dammit!!!!!

 

[Demilich]

Morningrise Dammit!!!!!

It's funny cause of your name and avatar.

 

[[KOTNO]Narrot]

Mayh!

 

[Sickman]

I can't believe Morningrise isn't running away with this vote. The last 10 minutes of "Black Rose Immortal" is more than enough reason to buy this album ahead of the others mentioned. And let's not forget "To Bid You Farewell," which would easily be my favorite Opeth song of all time. Morningrise just has a certain dark quality about it that their other albums don't come close to.

 

[Skullzz]

Get them all, or maybe just Morningrise. Or, get them all...

 

[Skullzz]

I can't believe Morningrise isn't running away with this vote. The last 10 minutes of "Black Rose Immortal" is more than enough reason to buy this album ahead of the others mentioned. And let's not forget "To Bid You Farewell," which would easily be my favorite Opeth song of all time. Morningrise just has a certain dark quality about it that their other albums don't come close to.

Wa-hey, a Bostonian Opeth fan who prefers Morningrise over the other albums! I'm in Peabody, 20 minutes from you.

 

[estimate]

Morningrise.

 

[estimate]

morningrise isn't running away with it because it's inferior to still life. period

You are inferior to me. Hence you lose. Period.

 

[T-Rat]

yeah!!! another near-boston opethian... we need to get together... (but i voted MAYH over Morningrise... )

 

[Sickman]

I actually live about about 40 minutes south of Boston in Franklin, MA. Close enough, I guess.

 

[magicelf]

Anyone would be fine, im sure you will eventually have all of them and all three are great albums so it doesnt make much difference.

 

[xsjado]

Ok I kinda abandond this post, but I ended up ordering My Arms, Your Hearse. And damn I'm glad I did.

(sorry for post bump lol)

 

[sweet majestic darkness]

Ok I kinda abandond this post, but I ended up ordering My Arms, Your Hearse. And damn I'm glad I did.

(sorry for post bump lol)

I voted for MAYH. But I say you should own them AAALLL!!!

 

[Detric]

My Arms, Your Hearse

 

[xsjado]

so you ordered the one that ended up in 3rd? i hate you more than anything

Lol yup. I actualy ordered it when it had 0 votes.

 

[Dreadful]

Of course he ordered My Arms Your Hearse, it's the best one on there. Instinct