What did you guys find disappointing in Enemies of Reality? I'm not one to compare, considering I'm not as much of a Nevermore fan, but I thought it was ok. I didn't go into it with any expectations.
If you didn't like EoR due to it's production, that's one thing. If you didn't like it because the songs themselves were crappy, then that's a bad sign for the band. History teaches us that once a band starts on the slippery slope, it's difficult to reverse the trend.
I also assume that Nevermore falls victim to always having people compare each new release with THAT one magnum opus, whichever one it might be -- Dreaming Neon Black I guess?