NitND vs. TGCD: Round 3

[BlueSky]

You know the drill.

For me Katatonia>>>Opeth so I had to go with Soil's Song by default. Although Idle Blood at least sets itself apart from the pack, unlike SS (or anything on TGCD for that matter).

 

[MadTinus]

Idle Blood pour moi.

 

[Cerulean]

The Opeth-ish influence in Idle Blood makes me shiver, it's one of my least liked Kata-tracks. Soil's Song gets my vote. Easy one

 

[the mourner13]

Easy one, Idle Blood has never sounded like Katatonia to me. Soil's Song all the way....

 

[gumtree]

I freaking love both albums, and I think some of these choices are just unfair, haha. But in this instance, I had to go for Soil's Song.

 

[Cressida]

Easy Soil's song by miles

 

[Code Against The Code]

Idle Blood by a long shot!

 

[isolation_years]

soils song


its pretty good

 

[Bereavement]

Soil's Song, no doubt

 

[Parasomnia]

I like Idle Blood a lot, but Soil's Song is amazing.

 

[noctambulant]

Idle blood for sure,I just think Soil's song is kinda silly

 

[LifeDepraved]

Idle Blood...one of my favs on the album. Not big on Soil's Song at all.

 

[gt_jen]

Soil song. but I'm really loving Idle Blood at the moment

 

[stefan86]

Two of the weaker song on the albums. Idle Blood for me though

 

[Nightmare_Heaven]

Soil's Song wins it....apparently Idle Blood was supposed to sound like Red House Painters but it just comes across sounding like Opeth. poor.

 

[Wildhoney]

Soil's song for sure.
Idle blood reminds me too much of Opeth in some passages.