Ok heres One hell of a guitar-off

[CAI]

Scott plays great the rythm guitar, but I think that Hetfield is a bit, just a bit better, and so is Rick Hunolt.
Kirk did great stuff 17-22 years ago (yesterday I was watching the Cliff `em all DvD, and thought how great and fast he was), I think that Gary Holt is on his average, and so is Lee Altus.

 

[Inside Out]

Hetfield, better, HA!

 

[JohnThrax]

ok, well Scott doesnt play lead AT ALL, so Kirk wins in technical ability

this poll is flawed

 

[AlexStomp]

I drank Sake after the LOA show a couple of weeks ago.

 

[mrthrax]

Well...

Scott is probably the better rhythm player but doesn't usually venture above the D string.

Kirk isn't very tight live and never has been. If he was stricter with himself I reckon he could have been a top class player.

thats what makes him have his own voice on the guitar man,a player that is very tight can be very very boring,especially live!