Rate A Natural Disaster

[Dazza81]

How would you rate it so?

 

[Mariner]

hmm how? compared to the other albums or just a rating for the sake of it?

 

[rafael]

I'll have it tomorrow or on monday

 

[Dazza81]

hmm how? compared to the other albums or just a rating for the sake of it?

As you wish, youre the judge

 

[cedarbreed]

9.5 because perfection is a myth

 

[Cerulean]

The only album I'd give a 10 is Eternity So I gave this one a 9.
Even Eternity isn't perfect though. Perfect enough to deserve a 10 anyway

 

[sol83]

i don't believe in 10's either. there is no perfect album. and i won't rate anathema's stuff. i can't.

 

[Sopel]

10 as since pentecost is each of is album is absolutely great. afdte and serenades 'onl' 9.5.

 

[John Carvajal]

can I rate 5 mp3's :Smug:


ps. I don't know why some fans like AFDTE and don't like AND

 

[Don Corleone]

i gave it 10/10. i completely love it...there isnt a single goddam track i dont like...so why shouldnt i give it a 10/10? HELL, I EVEN LIKE CHILDHOOD'S DREAM!

 

[Cerulean]

Harmonium is the only song on it I really dislike, all the others are winners.

 

[cedarbreed]

i gave it 10/10. i completely love it...there isnt a single goddam track i dont like...so why shouldnt i give it a 10/10? HELL, I EVEN LIKE CHILDHOOD'S DREAM!

But childhhod dream is ace !

 

[cedarbreed]

Harmonium is the only song on it I really dislike, all the others are winners.

But harmonium is ace

 

[Don Corleone]

But childhhod dream is ace !

OF COURSE IT IS!!! compared to the others on the album, though, it seems a bit weak but still i love it!

 

[Timmeth]

My favorite Anathema release next to "A Fine Day To Exit"...

 

[miranda B]

i only heard closer and i really like that one.

 

[Bastet]

it's the first album where i don't really dislike a single song

 

[eternalhours]

AND has had some bad reception on the Katatonia board.
But I still want this album!

 

[Aerwen]

Hm, I gave it a 9.0 coz I only gave Judgement a 10 and Alternative 4 a 9.5...
It deserves a good 3rd place in the ranking of all albums in my opinion...

 

[Timmeth]

The title track is my favorite next to "Pulled Under..."

This is really a strong CD music wise. It's very well done...