Rate A Natural Disaster

[Dazza81]

I gave it a 7.5. Its a better CD than AFDTE (6), but still too similar. They need to pump it up and plug in the guitars on more songs. And it doesnt even come close to the mighty 3, Eternity, Alternative 4 and Judgement. Still a good CD though.

 

[sol83]

i don't think they should pump up anything. cos then it would be like pretending. it has to be honest. they don't feel like playing heavy so there's no point in trying to play like that.

 

[Dazza81]

i don't think they should pump up anything. cos then it would be like pretending. it has to be honest. they don't feel like playing heavy so there's no point in trying to play like that.

Yeah, I totally agree with what you said. Its their music and art after all. I was just expressing my personal preference, but in no way am I expecting Anathema to change their style just to please me. Maybe I didnt choose the right words so I might have given that impression.

 

[Cenk]

so far the average of the votes from 25 people is 8.032

 

[PY]

so far the average of the votes from 25 people is 8.032

did you count the vote of the madman who gave 1 ?

 

[sol83]

Yeah, I totally agree with what you said. Its their music and art after all. I was just expressing my personal preference, but in no way am I expecting Anathema to change their style just to please me. Maybe I didnt choose the right words so I might have given that impression.

yeah, i get it, cool. i wouldn't say no to some pentecost-like doom parts but that would be like asking an elephant to do high jump or something...

 

[Cenk]

did you count the vote of the madman who gave 1 ?

yep. and the average is now 8.37, based on 27 votes

 

[toolsofthetrade]

almost what i voted. lets see

 

[Usherette]

9,5 for me

 

[ProgMetalFan]

1 (perhaps the worst album I've ever purchased)



I'm all for stylistic changes... but not when the sound morphs into... nothingness

 

[mehdi.i.e.e.e]

just out of curiosity, do you like the last nightingale album dude? you probably do cause you like evergrey.

 

[eternalsadness]

I give it 7.5. I find extremely boring closer (the worst song of the album) and songs like "electricity" and "childhood dream" itsnt that good.

 

[sol83]

 

[Quagmire]

For me it´s a 7.
I miss John´s songs. They have this special tension.

 

[Don Corleone]

1 (perhaps the worst album I've ever purchased)



I'm all for stylistic changes... but not when the sound morphs into... nothingness

the worst?

baaah

 

[Dazza81]

Keep em coming