I had clients that told me "Wow, you made our drums sound like the Black Album, that's fantastic... but we'd prefer and weaker sound actually please"... err... ok...
LMAO!....."Wow you made our drums sound like Metallica's Black Album.....YOU FUCKING PRICK WE HATE THAT ALBUM!! IT SUCKS! I HATE YOU! I HATE YOU!!! ARRRRRGGG!!!" *puts headstock through monitor*
what you guys all have to ask yourselves is what bob rock was thinking when he went for that particular sound. what were his motives? what was he trying to achieve? why that sort of sound over metallica's previous type of snares. as always it's all in context. put yourselves in rock's shoes and then think why it is there before deciding if it works or not.