SONG SURVIVOR - MEGADETH - KIMB - ROUND 1

[TechnicalBarbarity]

this is what i feel like when i hear a cover track on a 5 star album ....

 

[CiG]

Hahaha that face.

 

[jimmy101]

That's Dave's happy face though!

 

[HamburgerBoy]

The cover isn't really that light-hearted, it's pretty dirty and aggressive, and if you are listening to any of the bleeped remasters you cannot even judge the cover.

 

[PrincessHades]

Fuck you for encouraging me to vote on this.

I went with These Boots because its a cover (albeit a fucking kickass one), Chosen Ones because even though its a great song its kind of short and simple...if you were to ask me to list the tracklist from memory id probably forget that song, and Last Rites just because i had to vote for a third

 

[jimmy101]

The cover isn't really that light-hearted, it's pretty dirty and aggressive, and if you are listening to any of the bleeped remasters you cannot even judge the cover.

I've heard both, I just like the bleeped version for the comedy factor. It makes it sound like he's saying worse stuff than he actually is haha.

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

@challenge_everything lets see what 'ya got here pal

 

[challenge_everything]

@challenge_everything lets see what 'ya got here pal

I don't like Megadeth. There you go.

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

... in-crowder confirmed.

 

[CiG]

Even the in-crowd appreciate Rust in Peace. This fool is bin-crowd.

 

[jimmy101]

I don't like Megadeth. There you go.

 

[challenge_everything]

... in-crowder confirmed.

Not actually sure what this is supposed to mean. I make no secret of my ambivalence to most thrash, I thought that made me uncool around these parts

 

[HamburgerBoy]

Even the in-crowd appreciate Rust in Peace.

But how much? I'd be surprised if it made the 1990 top 10 of a wainds, Mort, or Slayed Necros list.

 

[CiG]

Enough to praise it frequently. Whether it does or doesn't make a top 10 doesn't disprove what I've said, especially since 1990 is an insanely stacked year.

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

Enough to praise it frequently.

Examples please. Find me posts form the two guys that HBB mentioned where they're praising the album. I dont think you're going to find many posts from Slayed, Manic, Mort, Wainds, Omni etc. I've rarely ever heard any of them mentioning RiP, let along praising it frequently ... outside of maybe Vegard, and hes even said a few times that's the only album from them he really liked. Most, if not all of them have clearly went out of their way to say they do not like the band

and our little british wanker has been the most vocal about it, lol....

Megadeth

If you can say Rust in Peace was good.....pfft....

i never really understood rust in peace

Oh, by the way, the other one was Peace Sells...But Who's Buying This Crap Album?

the best thing he's said about RiP is "i think its growing on me and im starting to appreciate it" once recently

 

[no country for old wainds]

i was an out crowd 14 year old opeth fan for two of those three posts tyvm. i agree megadeth aren’t an in-crowd staple though.

i really like the ‘big three’ tunes on that album and the rest i either mildly like or don’t care for, so pretty normie tastes in it i guess.

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

"arent an in-crowd staple"? Lol, how about "most of the in-crowd doesnt like Megadeth"? Disliking the band sounds like more of an in-crowd staple. I can find far more posts of you guys talking shit about the band than the other way around. Even Bromni used to talk shit about them and said the only album she liked was basically Peace Sells, that's before he started posting with his other "personality" who totally loved Megadeth.

I did find a few posts where you said you enjoy some of their early stuff, so why havent you voted here?

EDIT:

peace sells > rust in peace i agree but they're both mostly crap

 

[no country for old wainds]

yeah i really like this album actually, 'tis my fav dethameg. it's a pain in the ass trying to decide my third vote.

 

[Vegard Pompey]

I like everything up to Rust in Peace moderately and I fucking love Rust in Peace.

 

[no country for old wainds]

i'd like us to do all the classic megadeth albums, in any case. all the classic 'big four' albums would be fun actually (although i agree a bunch of other thrash bands should be a higher priority than anthrax)