RashomoN
Eran
thjasi said:OK, Hmm, so what do you prefer!? Monarchy, Dictatorship...???
Certainly not the ideas of a state Plato brought up in the "books" 2-10.
He may have centered his idea of a state around JUSTICE, but he structures his state in three parts: 1. "Rulers" (Philosophers ), 2. "Guards" and 3. Farmer/Workmen (which means pretty much everyone )
Plato thinks that we get our talents/abilities before we are born (Lachesis Myth) and based on our talents the Guards decide which of the 3 parts a young child will be part of...blablabla you know what I mean
Bottom line: Plato may be right on a number of subjects but I prefer many modern democracies to his state, in which he creates 3 pretty much fixed categories.
I mean, what's a better alternative compared to democracy...ok Utopia, but that might be a problem
o.k......I agree.....thats why i didn't describe all what he wrote......
Plato was modern for his time.....and doesn't really fit our time.....though some ideas fit all eras......
I just said that the idea of democracy is not what people had made of it.....unfortunately......
the basics are great......but it is not rational, because of the human nature.....
and.....no, I guess there are no other ways......
:Smug: