They wouldn't, but you would probably still be more than satisfied with the Super Distortion's tone. It's not nearly as bright sounding though.
Also, you don't want to put the Super 2 in the bridge position, especially with your tastes. However, if you were looking for something darker and slightly more dynamic it would work.
Still though, you want the J-50 with abq boost. The Super Distortion is great too and you wouldn't be disappointed by it but it's not going to give you the sound you're looking for.