booB said:
Personally, I definitely think they are headliner caliber, but I can't help thinking they'd suffer from the Rage Effect
I agree with all of your points, Bob. I'm a pretty big fan of VS, in at least a small part thanks to Glenn. (I think it was Sean or Blaine who sent me that first compilation tape, complete with then only-on-vinyl stuff from earlier albums, then Glenn sent me a tape of
HoA1.) For years Glenn has tried and tried to get VS for PPUSA, but there wasn't ever any reply to his inquiries, which of course never made sense. Hopefully that'll be a good question for the interview to accompany the PPVIII program!
When I read that the third band was announced and cruised over to the progpowerusa.com site to check it out, I had to do a double take. Then my jaw dropped open for about a minute. Of course they are one of the few bands I've always dreamed of seeing but have NEVER had even a chance to. For me they rank up there with Savatage as one of the classic American metal bands that has recorded for years and years. It's practically criminal that they are even less known here in the US than the 'Tage.
I think their association with Manowar really picked up with
Invictus, when David started singing so similar to Eric Adams'
Kings of Metal-onward vocal approach. Still, they had similar origins, similar inspirations, but obviously VS is far more classy, far smarter, at least in a compositional sense. Anyway, there are so many timeless VS songs, and this festival appearance should definitely be a 'best of' approach.
The new album seems a bit controversial. I for one definitely like it, especially since David has stopped sounding so much like Eric, and the project is more original. The production is fairly lacking, ESPECIALLY the piss-poor weak, fake drum sounds (most likely triggered or v-drums). Just listen to that abysmal hi-hat! The guitars are also fairly weak, which was a problem for the HoA albums as well. Keys and vox sound great, as alway, though also as always some of the keyboard patches seem poorly chosen/weak.
I wouldn't mind hearing a song or two from
Visions of Eden, especially the very diverse "Black Light on Black," but really we need the best stuff: "The Fall of Rome (Cry for Pompeii)," "Emalaith," "Sword of the Gods," "Noble Savage," "Blood and Gasoline," etc. etc. etc. There are tons of great classic VS songs. Only an hour to play makes choosing from them pretty hard, especially as so many are longer. I wish they had a longer slot but I totally understand why they don't. Hopefully, even this late in their career, they can pick up a lot of new fans. Everyone who likes the band and has seen them live says they are an outstanding live act.
First Redemption, now VS. This is turning into the ProgPower of my dreams.
Of course something will come along and make it more real, maybe Symphorce or some crap like that.
Now and Forever,
lmjh