well i don't see what the problem is...i've been an Evergrey fan from the beginning, and personally i think the new cd is fantastic. i will agree that yes it is different in many ways compared to their previous releases, but it's still Evergrey. and Evergrey still kicks ass. and honestly the guitar tone is not that different..it's less subtle now i think, and some of the leads sound like something much different..a harsher sound kinda..hard to describe.
honestly my only complaint would be that it was quite short, coming only to 44:47. for having 12 songs, that's pretty short. but the songs i thought were still great. and the emotion that is always present in Evergrey songs is, of course, still there. and the lyrics, as always, are freakin awesome. the drums i felt somewhat left something to be desired, as they did less then they're capable of. so if anything was more commercial sounding i'd say it was the drums..but all in all i really like the cd and was glad to recieve my pre-ordered copy which, might i also add, is signed. \m/