Who writes better songs, Duncan or Mick?

[flebbie]

Lets just judge the Antimatter songs to give Mick a fair chance.

 

[Susie]

Mick does

 

[Allan]

I smell controversy. I'll avoid it by giving an edge to Dunc for the songs on "Saviour" and to Mick for the ones on "Lights Out".

 

[sol83]

i cant vote. i mean, dunc has wrote some incredible tunes over the years. but i like mick's songs more on lights. so it's really hard to say.

 

[Dhatura]

Yeah, I think we should make it a bit more specific era-wise. I don't know Mick's pre-Antimatter work either.

 

[flebbie]

Yeah, I think we should make it a bit more specific era-wise. I don't know Mick's pre-Antimatter work either.

I already did. I told this poll is only based on Antimatter stuff, so we're not going to look at Duncans Anathema songs or Micks pre-Antimatter work.

 

[cedarbreed]

Well I can't really vote either, I like Dunc's song on Saviour best. But on Lights Out, Mick's are my favourites !

 

[Allan]

Well I can't really vote either, I like Dunc's song on Saviour best. But on Lights Out, Mick's are my favourites !

Wow, agreement again, are you sure you like Wings of God?

 

[Mariner]

micks songwriting is easier to get onto it. i like the darkness in duncs songs more for saviour. tho micks songs on lo are black as fuck as well. tho i prefer songs with easy refrains, sing along-ers... so im with cedar , dunc for saviour and mick for lo.

nem.

 

[donkho]

"...i've a solution.... final solution..."

 

[Falconspirit]

I say Duncan has been writing songs for a long time, as some of you have said. so I think I'll wait a bit to see more of Mick's work so I can at least compare and contrast them and judge. But I reckon both are great songwriters, and their work on both Antimatter albums prooves it.
cheers all..

 

[Cerulean]

Can't decide, but they are an excellent team for sure. Their style is not really compareable, but they fit each other very well on the albums.

 

[the_good_son141]

since lo is my fav of the two cds i must give the credit to mick sorry

 

[Mariner]

i wonder, what do you think about "duncs' are best on saviour and micks' on lo" ?
it seems most of us think that way

 

[cedarbreed]

Wow, agreement again, are you sure you like Wings of God?

Yeah sorry

 

[Allan]

Yeah sorry

It's ok, I forgive you. I guess, we can't all have ultra-perfect taste in music like me :Spin: .

 

[Don Corleone]

both, i'd say. i even like the "lights out" on LO! it's so trippy and dark. very disturbing...

 

[Dhatura]

I already did. I told this poll is only based on Antimatter stuff, so we're not going to look at Duncans Anathema songs or Micks pre-Antimatter work.

Interestingly enough, when I read the poll and all the posts, I didn't see your first sentence, sorry

A sure sign I'm getting old.

 

[Dhatura]

Wow, I made it a draw

 

[toolsofthetrade]

yeh its not that relevant really, and a matter of arses and holes and that