I don't get it, you're saying that people only like AtL for the nostalgia, and that it's actually not good and not considered a thrash classic. I'm pretty sure most people consider it to be a landmark album in thrash. It has classic songs, great hooks (I still can't figure out why you think the album has no hooks), classic solos, and memorable album art.
Any other album by Anthrax or any other band has no bearing on how good/bad AtL is, that's a terrible argument for justifying why you don't like it.
With this said, PoT is better.
No no, not at all. What I'm saying is simply that if we were to put the fact that an opinion can never be used as empirical evidence aside, I'd like to know what draws so many people to AtL.
I'm saying that if I were to extrapolate what I perceive as quality in the songs on AtL and compare it with something like PoT, it doesn't hold up that it's such a better album (as well as one could be objective about it...it's still just opinion) according to the fans UNLESS they were looking at it through the lens of nostalgia.
I'm saying I would UNDERSTAND how they felt it was a better album than all the rest if it was based on nostalgia because that would make sense to me. What DOESN'T make sense is how (in my mind, at least) albums like PoT is so OBVIOUSLY superior in nearly every way to AtL, yet everyone still clamors for AtL. I want to know WHY this is, because several of you have even conceded that PoT, if not a better album, is at least just as good as it.
Comparing the two albums, AtL pales in comparison to me.
However, nostalgia is a powerful thing; when you're taken back in time to a good or even bad time by something you love, it's very powerful on the human psyche. I would understand if it were someone's first album, the first time they were introduced to thrash metal, etc. What doesn't make sense is that I simply don't see just how great this album is when they've done albums much superior to it, at least in my mind.
Look, this isn't meant piss anyone off, I'm just looking for a straightforward answer with actual reasons to back it up.