aortizjr
Member
I am really surpirsed to hear you say this. I built the NYdave box without the pots (no volume and no 'impedence' pot). It was too loud! I had to put in the volume pot to get it back to a normal level?!?!?!
Can this depend on what pickups are being used? I am a passive guy.
That said, I still plan on building the Jenson box as well so that I can try both.
Trent
I think it depends on the output level on your interface and how hot the guitar is tracked and such. I guess it isn't completely cranked, but I keep the output pretty high. The Jensen I definitely keep much lower, but all the way up it can add a lot of additional saturation.
But the more I mess with this, kind of the more I don't think it really matters that much. The transformer is primarily there to help with buzzing and break ground loops. Many studios just run an aux and control the volume with the aux. Essentially just turning down the volume till it sounds right. Or DI backwards, even cheap ones. If you open those, the transformers are typically really cheap.. but sound fine and trace fine on a scope.
As explained in the thread I posted above, it goes into more detail about the power handling and impedance and such.
So I wouldn't sweat it too much. Either one will work just fine. There are other schematics on the net. With parts and shipping $50 is about right... add the time it takes to build... + the cost of soldering iron and solder if you don't have one, then a drill... so if you don't have the tools... the buying one is a good deal.
DIY... much like recording... is a labor of love though...