Blackwater Park Vs Still Life

[hibernal_dream]

Saying Harvest is better than Benighted is insanity.

 

[bens0n]

wow nice comparison, I have to agree with you, and I cant wait for the remastered version march 31st

 

[forza]

Saying Harvest is better than Benighted is insanity.

how so? i man yeh they're both great, i just prefer Harvest to Bengihted.

 

[aaronjs]

song for song i definitely go with SL. In my opinion if you line up the songs the way people have been doing i only give the edge to BWP's title track, definitely an epic album closer. i can't wait for the remaster, definitely worth treating myself to

 

[Holocaust on the Moon]

The Moor - The Leper Affinity (tie)
Godhead's Lament - Bleak
Benighted - Harvest
Moonlapse Vertigo - The Drapery Falls
Face of Melinda - Dirge for November
SPD - Funeral Portrait
White Cluster - BWP

I like Blackwater Park, but I like Still Life so much more.

 

[Obtuse]

Blackwater Park just doesn't do it for me. Apart from Harvest and BWP, I don't really like it. I'll take Beneath the Mire over Drapery Falls any day.

 

[griev0r]

Saying Harvest is better than Benighted is insanity.

At least one person agrees with me.

Ok I guess I'll lend my useless opinion to this as well.

The Moor - The Leper Affinity I have to agree for tie here, both amazing songs.
Godhead's Lament - Bleak
Benighted - Harvest
Moonlapse Vertigo - The Drapery Falls
Face of Melinda - Dirge for November
SPD - Funeral Portrait
White Cluster - BWP

 

[IntoPhagist]

Ill pick mine right now....

The Leper Affinity and The Moor are both epic openers but I choose....Leper
Godhead's Lament and Bleak is hard also but I def choose Godhead's
Harvest is awe-inspiring IMO...Benighted is dark/creepy/odd/ and not my cop o tea. So Harvest!
Moonlapse Vertigo Vs. The Drapery Falls...Moonlapse Vertigo Wins
Dirge for November beats out Face of Melinda IMO
Serenity Painted Death is the winner here over Funeral Portrait.....SPD is one of Opeth's best ever.
White Cluster And BlackWater Park are just as hard as The moor/TLA but I have to go with BWP.

So overall I always pick BWP...even though still life is like my 2nd favorite album.

 

[Rezard]

The Moor - The Leper Affinity
Godhead's Lament - Bleak
Benighted - Harvest
Moonlapse Vertigo - The Drapery Falls
Face of Melinda - Dirge for November
SPD - Funeral Portrait
White Cluster - BWP

Definitely Still Life, but BWP is a great album nonetheless.
That being said, I guess I'm the only one around here who doesn't appreciate "The Drapery Falls" and "Blackwater Park" that much, so...

 

[kendoji]

Opeth's albums are all too good for me to rank, other than MAYH being a somewhat obvious overall favorite.