Controversial opinions on metal

[Vegard Pompey]

I think it would be more controversial to say that they are actually decent. I'd say they are.

 

[whiskey funeral]

Oh no he di'int.

 

[mutantllama]

 

[Satanstoenail]

TDEP fucking rule you fucking fuckbunch of fucking fucks

 

[S<issors]

Probably not controversial but: Amorphis - Silent Waters is a good album.

Listened to it while lifting today and thought to myself "wow, this is better than the last time I listened to it."

weirdly I had the precise same revelation while also lifting

exercise: the key to appreciating Silent Waters.

 

[~Neurotica]

TDEP fucking rule you fucking fuckbunch of fucking fucks

.

 

[The Butt]

I got Ire Works for Christmas once.

I wanted to rip out a baby's heart and shove it up somebody's asshole.

 

[Gold]

ire works sucks. calculating infinity, irony is a dead scene, and miss machine are all awesome.

 

[The Butt]

And I heard one good song from Miss Machine (Sunshine the Werewolf), but didn't care for the rest at all.

Guess I'll try the others you mentioned. I'm doubtful though.

 

[~Neurotica]

Miss Machine has different vocalist than previous stuff... I do find it good though. You definitely need to check their earlier albums.
Their new release is good too, though I realize that all their albums are very different.

 

[Gold]

if the song "when good dogs do bad things" doesnt get you into them then nothing will. Its off the Irony is a dead scene EP

 

[Bitencourt29]

Miss Machine has different vocalist than previous stuff... I do find it good though. You definitely need to check their earlier albums.
Their new release is good too, though I realize that all their albums are very different.

Miss Machine is their best album, imo. The new one has a couple interesting songs, but nothing special. You're spot on, each TDEP album is very different.

They're a weird band tbh. Some great stuff, some awful stuff.

 

[The Ozzman]

This is in terms of the band Toxik:

Charles Sabin > Mike Sanders and Sabin is a huge reason why Think This is the best of the two records the band did

 

[divine_torture]

Meh, that's not controversial. It's just the way it is tbh.

 

[The Ozzman]

I think it's controversial for this board at least

 

[divine_torture]

Fuck it. You know what you're talkin about. And I agree. Those who disagree need to try again.

 

[Ross]

not sure if its controversial but

Nightingale > Edge of Sanity

 

[J.]

that's not controversial, just bullshit

 

[Ross]

i beg to differ, it was very tough though

 

[sarkain]

Here's some of my premeditated blasphemy:

Iron Maiden sucks, I never liked a single song from them. I do however respect them.

Judas Priest never clicked with me either, but I have huge respect for them.

Death Magnetic was actually a good album.

Pantera is fucking awesome. (Not really that controversial, but they get a lot of shit on this forum)

United Abominations is Megadeth's best album. That's right, it beats even Rust In Peace etc.

Destruction's Thrash Anthems is great, just like Testament's First Strike Still Deadly.

Slayer made a great comeback to form with Christ Illusion.

That's pretty much it.