Dakryn's Batshit Theory of the Week



There's an irony here in that a legitimate critique of JP involves dismissing the basis for the broad-based post-modern critique. Not that this is new or anything.
 
I remember when that article was published. I didn't pay much attention to it, honestly. I haven't read Nagel's book, but I think the critics/skeptics are right. It strikes me as an instance of someone retroactively imposing necessity onto an evolutionary contingency. Nagel's right that, in a strictly evolutionary sense, the emergence of consciousness was highly unlikely--that there is a virtual infinity of alternative paths that evolution could have taken (not to mention the universe). Teleology explains away the unlikelihood, but at the cost of ignoring entire blackboards of chaos mathematics that support the "fluke" theory. Every single branch of evolutionary existence is (or at least began) as a highly unlikely, highly unpredictable phenomenon. It all could have been otherwise.

Coincidentally, that article pairs nicely with Peter Watts's recent little invective against Bernardo Kastrup's recent article in The Journal of Consciousness Studies: https://www.rifters.com/crawl/?p=8255
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Dak and CiG
yo @Dak, i heard you calculated and made up an IQ score for yourself in the 160's(lmao) and then got called out on in later when you said that you never actually took an IQ test. :lol: Is this true?

Not to my knowledge. Unless I drunk posted some bullshit like 8-10 years ago. It's true I have not taken an IQ test, but I have taken other tests with high correlations with IQ test results and I also give IQ tests, and my best informed estimate is in the range of 125-130.

Edit: I think I posted about GRE correlations, and I have a super high IQ correlation with the verbal subtest, but not with the quantitative, and I explained that. If someone wants to run with a single sentence and ignore everything else that's on them.
 
Not to my knowledge. Unless I drunk posted some bullshit like 8-10 years ago. It's true I have not taken an IQ test, but I have taken other tests with high correlations with IQ test results and I also give IQ tests, and my best informed estimate is in the range of 125-130.
so you're saying you never made up an IQ score for yourself? Or at least you don't remember doing so?
 
Last edited: