I have to say...I'm not all that overwhelmed. Everything I've heard so far was that this was supposed to be a revitalization of the band...that they were supposed to plug into the vibe of Lightning and Master and use that energy to make this record. Sure it may not SOUND exactly like those two albums (And really who wants a blatant ripoff of an earlier album anyways?) but it was to put the band in the mind frame they had when they were doing those albums back in the early 80's. Lean, mean, angry with a chip on their shoulder and trying to prove to everyone else in the world that they were now the new force to be reckoned with.
But I don't really hear that in this song. They're trying to be lean and mean....but it still has that air of being tired and feeling run down. I hate to say that, because I would love nothing more then for these guys to explode onto the world with this record and prove everybody wrong.
But...I'm not seeing that happening with this song. Maybe the band from 1985 could have made this song work. But the band from 2008 sounded tired, like they were just phoning it in. Is it better then St Anger? Yes...light years better. And for that, at least, I am relieved. But if this song had been heard as a demo during the recording of Master of Puppets, it would have been thrown in the trash (Or at least stripped down, reworked and reworked some more to try and come up with something acceptable0. Just my very humble (and quite possibly wrong) opinion, Folks.
I will buy this record the day it hits the shelves. I've bought every other Metallica record the day of release since Ride the Lightning even though for the last two decades, I've been somewhat less then enthusiastic about it.
But maybe this record will prove me wrong. Maybe that was just one weak song and the rest will more then make up for it. That's what I'm hoping for anyways.