Deliverence VS BWP (the songs)

[Bleakest Harvest]

DELIVERANCE!
And BWP was my favourite Opeth album before Deliverance came out, which makes Deliverance my new Favourite Opeth.

 

[DivideByZero]

Amusing that people keep comparing albums, when it's the songs he's referring to.

I'd rather listen to Blackwater Park.

 

[Masters Apprentice]

HE'S TALKING ABOUT THE SONGS CALLED DELIVERANCE AND BWP NOT THE ALBUMS

 

[SoulVomitor]

Deliverance.

 

[Static]

I actually think talking about the albums would be more interesting than talking bout the songs.

Nuff said.

 

[thirdeye]

hmm thats hard for me to answer song by song...its a toss up i suppose, but ill have to wait a while to really say...shit i dont even have the real copy of deliverance yet. nobody has it around detroit! bastards...

 

[phon1c]

Blackwater park is stunning. so, that. Nothing can beat that intro with the ebow, nothing i tell you!!

 

[Stinkfist]

Deliverance as it has clean vocals.

 

[inferenzum]

bwp has clean vocals too... deliverance is more repetitive and motonous... but it does have a direct drive, and it's darker and heavier, which is always a plus. but the songs don't flow as well. and i don't know what the title track is all about but they could have done better with a lot of the movements. easy for me to say, since as a musician i probably couldnt, but hey what's life without pointless idealism? the vote says BWP beats D. on both counts, individual songs and as a whole, but not by a hell of a lot.

 

[GoufCustom]

Blackwater Park, but Deliverance reels me in just as well.

 

[shivering corpse]

the songs Deliverance vs. BWP...deliverance
the albums...hmmmm, very tough to say...will get back with you in a few weeks after Deliverance doesn't seems so brand new

 

[Battman]

BWP doesn't not have clean vocals. Good lord people, he asked if you prefer Deliverance (the song) or BWP (the song). I think maybe 5 people actually answered his question.

BWP definitely for me.

 

[Nugent Goes AOL]

BWP baby

 

[demon talented]

I prefer the song Deliverance to the song Blackwater Park.

Very dark, interesting lyrical approach in the song.

 

[inferenzum]

BWP totally kills the song Deliverance. no question. i remember when i first heard BWP i stuck my cd player on 'repeat track' for like an hour

come to think of it, i think the song BWP offers almost as much ingenuity as the entire Deliverance album does.. not to discredit deliverance.

 

[Martin 78]

Hi.....I`m new here...and I wanted to say that I think "deliverance" is the better one.....
but" damnation" surely is better than both...

 

[/Z/]

Unfortunatly, the thread post can be taken to mean either the names of the songs or all the songs on the album. I hate the semantics of the English language. I, however, think that Deliverance is better as a song.

 

[Speedkill]

Come on, people, even I figured it out. I had to be corrected, but still.

 

[Hondo]

Oh. I thought he meant.. like song by song. Which I guess doesn't make a lot of sense sinc ethat's basically comparing albums.

Well, my post still applies, then. Deliverance is deeper and prettier, BWP makes me want to jump around and hit people. I can't decide.

 

[Morfiend]

Song: "Deliverance"

I consider both songs to be among my favorite Opeth songs so this was kind of tough. Even though I've only heard "Deliverance" 5 times or so I'd say I enjoyed it more after those 5 listens then I did with "Blackwater Park".

Album:Blackwater Park

From top to bottom I think it's the best Opeth album. Also, with the addition of the two acoustic bonus tracks on the limited edition copy it's even better. Although I like Deliverance a lot, it didn't make my jaw drop like BWP and SL did.